The map that keeps getting redrawn.

Underdog Fantasy Legal States 2026: Where Pick'em Is and Isn't Allowed

Close-up of the UEFA Champions League trophy on a pedestal indoors
Close-up of the UEFA Champions League trophy on a pedestal indoors. Photo: Matheus Bertelli / Pexels

The short answer

Underdog operates pick'em fantasy contests in ~30+ states, but the map shifted hard in 2024-26 as states ruled pick'em contests are 'prop betting in disguise.' California, Florida, New York and others restricted or banned the pick'em format; Underdog now splits into Pick'em (some states), Pick'em Champions (other states), and a prediction-market product through a CFTC-registered exchange.

In this article

Underdog built a billion-dollar fantasy company on pick'em — pick more/less on player stats, get paid multipliers — and then spent two years watching states decide that pick'em looks a lot like prop betting. The result is America's most confusing product map: different formats allowed in different states, product names changed to comply, and a company that pivoted part of its business to CFTC-regulated event contracts to sidestep the whole fight.

The pick'em problem

Traditional fantasy (compete against other players for a prize pool) is legal in most states. Pick'em — where you compete against the house's posted multipliers — triggered a legal wave in 2023-25 as regulators ruled it sports wagering in fantasy clothing. New York's gaming commission banned the format; California's AG declared pick'em illegal under state law; Florida sent cease-and-desists; and a dozen states issued formal rulings or informal pressure. Underdog's response was to rebrand and rebuild: 'Pick'em' became peer-to-peer 'Champions' contests in states that demanded it, and the company added a prediction-market lane for states where even that wasn't enough.

  • Pick'em (house-banked format) is available in roughly 30 states but the map is volatile — Underdog's own availability page is the only reliable current source.
  • Pick'em Champions (peer-to-peer) was built for restrictive states — California and others where the against-the-house format was banned but competing against other users might survive.
  • States with outright bans or exits include Arizona, Colorado, Idaho, Michigan, Montana, Nevada, New York, Washington and others that ruled pick'em is sports betting requiring a license.
  • The prediction-market pivot: Underdog now offers CFTC-regulated event contracts in partnership — available where federal derivatives law, not state gaming law, governs. It's the industry's bet that federal registration beats state fights.
  • Best Ball and drafts remain the most stable products — traditional fantasy contests with the widest legal footprint.

Why the map keeps changing

Every state that regulates pick'em forces a version of the same question: is this fantasy or betting? Underdog's products evolve to land on whichever side each state's answer allows — which is why the state list is a moving target and why checking the app's availability notice (not a blog post) is the only reliable answer for 'is Underdog legal here.'

Context: prediction markets vs sportsbooks, legal online casino states, and sports betting's map.

Sources